Recently a UK poll listed "The Top-Ten Iconic Dresses of the Past 50 Years." It was a trifle, really, an innocuous survey generated by the online fashion retailer Offers Supermarket, meant as pure escapist fun, with the results decidedly British: Geri Halliwell's Union Jack dress, worn to the 1997 Brit Awards, topped the vote with 82 percent, which should in itself prove that this list of "iconic dresses" was never meant to be a global representation. (Besides, how can you take seriously any poll that lists Bjork's swan dress as "iconic"?)
But here's the thing: Others picked up the poll and ran with it.
Daily Telegraph Fashion Director Hilary Alexander
posted it, instantly lending credibility to the survey. Fashionista.com found this a little objectionable and chose to publish its
own list of iconic dresses. But Fashionista.com went for a combo of dresses and iconic women, diluting the true spirit of the original question: What would you choose as the top-10 iconic dresses of the past 50 years?
Such a list is always going to be a little subjective, so with that in mind, here's what I would choose, with the caveat that in a couple of cases I expanded beyond 50 years -- but as you'll see below, I'm not the first to do this ...
10. Marilyn Monroe's white halter dress in The Seven Year Itch: I had to laugh when this dress made the original list, if only because
Seven Year Itch is a 1955 film, putting it out of 50-year contention. But I would still include it, because a) It truly is an iconic dress, with designers such as Michael Kors noting that they continue to reinterpret it, and b) it allows me to include a couple of others that fall outside the scope of the past five decades of fashion. To wit:
9. Grace Kelly's dress in Rear Window: The black and white gown she wears in her entrance scene in Hitchcock's 1954 film was designed by Edith Head, a collaboration that helped cement Kelly's status as a fashion icon. You still see elements of this dress walking down runways -- Oscar de la Renta and Monique Lhuillier are two designers who spring to mind.
8. Elizabeth Taylor's Place in the Sun gown: This 1951 film established Taylor as an adult actress, and her entrance gown (also designed by Head) was an instant sensation with its strapless, floral-bedecked bodice and tulle skirt. If you went to a prom in the first half of the 1950s, chances are you wore a copy of this dress. And PS, how many tulle-skirted princess gowns did we see at the most recent Costume Institute Gala?
7. Jean Harlow's Dinner at Eight goddess gowns: Designed by Adrian, Jean Harlow's bias-cut gowns in 1933's
Dinner at Eight established her role as the decade's ultimate sex symbol. Bias-cut charmeuse gowns, meanwhile, continue their dominance as the ultimate in red-carpet glam.
6. Halle Berry's Oscar moment: When Fashionista.com reinterpreted the poll, they chose Gwyneth Paltrow's pink Ralph Lauren, worn in 1999 when she won for
Shakespeare in Love. That's a lovely dress, but I remember thinking at the time that it seemed a bit ill-fitting in the bodice, and a return to those photos does little to change that opinion. Instead, I'm going for the Elie Saab gown Halle Berry wore in 2002 when she won for
Monster's Ball. With its richly embroidered illusion bodice and spectacular fit, I find this dress to be more memorable -- aided by Berry's historic win -- while it also established Saab as a designer of note.
5. Elizabeth Hurley and Jennifer Lopez (tie): I'm listing these two memorable looks as a tie because I think neither outshines the other as the dominant red-carpet moment. Hurley became an instant celebrity in 1994 because of the Versace safety-pin dress she wore to then-boyfriend Hugh Grant's
Four Weddings and a Funeral premiere; six years later, Lopez likewise made worldwide headlines for the Versace gown she wore to the 2000 Grammys, a green palm-print chiffon that made low-cut a classic understatement.
4. YSL's Mondrian dresses: This and #2 were the duo I couldn't believe made no one's list. When Yves Saint Laurent launched his Mondrian collection in 1965, he became a global sensation for his shift dresses based on Piet Mondrian's graphic paintings of the '20s-'40s. It was the first collection in which Saint Laurent employed an overt artistic reference, and alongside fellow designers such as Pierre Cardin, Saint Laurent launched the decade's Mod movement in fashion.
3. Diana's wedding dress: A tiny ache in my heart arose when researching the ideal photo for this dress. I was one of millions of American girls who planted herself in front of a TV at 4 am to watch start-to-finish coverage of this wedding on 29 July 1981, and Diana's gown, designed by instantly famous British couturiers Elizabeth and David Emanuel, quickly became the world's most coveted wedding dress. I also think the silk-taffeta gown, with its enormous sleeves and profusion of ruffles, perfectly captures the mood of the '80s: I can't think of another 20th-century wedding that matched the pomp and circumstance of Charles and Diana, and the more-is-more design of her gown was an early sign of that decade's fashion excess.
2. Diane von Furstenberg's wrap dress: You talk about iconic dresses and don't include DVF's wrap?!? The designer made
Newsweek's cover in March 1976 because she quite simply revolutionized fashion with her jersey dresses, which allowed women to feel sexy and confident in the workplace. It was an iconic moment for both fashion and feminism, and the wrap dress continues its popularity as a must-have to this day. In 2006, Mattel released a
collectible Barbie wearing a pink DVF wrap. 'Nuff said.
1. Audrey Hepburn's Breakfast at Tiffany's dress: Without a doubt, fashion's biggest heavy-sigh moment. By the time
Breakfast at Tiffany's premiered in 1961, the collaboration and deep friendship between Hepburn and Hubert de Givenchy was known worldwide, so when she saunters down a dawn-lit Fifth Avenue in the opening shot of the film, your mind steps outside the story for a brief second to marvel at the perfection of Givenchy's black column gown with the graphic back, accessorized so sublimely with gloves and pearls.
Selecting a list of iconic dresses likely will always be a little polarizing (I don't, for example, list any dresses worn by Jacqueline Kennedy, such as the Oleg Cassini shift she wore on Easter Sunday 1963 or the Givenchy gown she wore during the famed Paris trip she took with JFK in 1961). But it's obvious that when it comes to Hepburn and Givenchy, on this we can all agree.